Questions about how individual parts of claim 1 might be changed. A question may describe something different from what the claim language recites, or a version of it; no view is offered on which.
1.1Automatic evaluation of both configurations
What ifWhat if the planner always evaluates both plate positions on a machine with a permanently installed motorized range shifter?
Claim language“an availability selection”
The planner generates retracted-plate and inserted-plate candidates for every field from two commissioned beam models. A geometry calculation removes candidates that fail clearance limits, and the optimizer compares the remaining candidates using target and organ dose objectives.
1.2Selection from approved patient plans
What ifWhat if the treatment system retrieves a previously approved plan for the patient by matching the anatomy observed at the fraction?
Claim language“optimizing the proton therapy treatment plan”
A plan library links each approved set of beam energies, spot weights, and hardware settings to a reference image and anatomy thresholds. The treatment system registers the fraction image, applies those thresholds, and retrieves the stored beam settings for the matching anatomy.
1.2Passive field calculation by geometry
What ifWhat if a passive scattering plan derives its field settings from target geometry and commissioned lookup tables?
Claim language“optimizing the proton therapy treatment plan”
The planner uses the deepest and shallowest water-equivalent target depths to select the beam range and spread-out Bragg peak width from commissioned tables. It derives the aperture outline and compensator thickness from the beam's-eye projection and ray depths, then calculates the resulting three-dimensional dose for review.
1.3Fixed plate state per field
What ifWhat if a depth rule fixes the range shifter position for each field before spot optimization begins?
Claim language“optimizing selective use of the selectively deployable range shifter”
The planning system compares the shallowest water-equivalent target depth in each field with the commissioned minimum range for the retracted plate. It assigns the inserted position when that depth falls below the minimum range and checks geometric clearance for that position. The optimizer loads the beam model for the assigned position and varies spot weights with the position held fixed.
Section 2 · machine-generated
Variations
Further arrangements of the same subject matter, described here as of the publication date at the foot of this page.
Other field of use
Proton irradiation of layered test coupons
A research beamline places a retractable range shifter upstream of a fixture that holds layered material coupons. The planning computer reads the available shifter positions and uses measured depth-dose curves for each position and beam energy. It selects a shifter position, beam energy, and delivered charge for each exposure to match the prescribed dose in the selected layer.
Component substitution
Rotary wheel with polyethylene sectors
A motorized wheel with an open aperture and two solid polyethylene sectors of different thicknesses replaces a translating range shifter. Each indexed position has a measured water-equivalent thickness and a beam model that accounts for scattering. The optimizer evaluates the available positions, and the delivery controller enables the beam only when the wheel encoder confirms the planned index.
Parameter or scale variation
Four settings for shallow target planning
A range-shifter cassette provides four calibrated settings of 0, 15, 30, and 45 millimeters of water-equivalent thickness. The planning computer calculates dose for each available setting using the measured depth-dose and lateral beam profiles at the planned air gap. It selects one setting for the entire field by comparing target coverage and dose to surrounding tissue across the candidate plans.
Combination with existing systems
Range planning with respiratory gating
A planning computer receives phase-resolved images and the permitted delivery window from a respiratory gating system. It evaluates each available shifter setting across the breathing phases within that window and selects the setting and spot weights using phase-specific dose calculations. During delivery, the controller requires both a confirmed shifter position and an open respiratory gate before enabling the beam.
Automated or data-driven variant
Measured beam profiles update dose models
A multilayer ionization chamber records depth-dose curves downstream of the range shifter at commissioned beam energies. Software fits water-equivalent thickness and distal falloff parameters for each shifter setting and compares the fits with the measured curves. The planning computer uses the accepted parameters to recalculate dose for each available setting before ranking candidate plans.
Range selection across setup uncertainties
The planning computer generates dose scenarios from patient setup offsets, stopping-power uncertainty, and measured variation in the installed shifter thickness. For each available shifter setting, it calculates spot doses across the scenarios and optimizes spot weights against target coverage and normal tissue dose limits. It ranks the resulting plans by their worst-case objective value and records the selected setting with the delivery parameters.
Specific version of a part
Per field availability setting
A planning workstation stores a per-field setting that permits or prohibits range shifter insertion. The control circuit reads the setting from the field record and enables the corresponding commissioned beam models for optimization.
Dose based spot weight optimization
The planning processor uses patient imaging and commissioned beam data to calculate each candidate spot's dose contribution to the target and nearby organs. A constrained solver adjusts nonnegative spot weights to meet target coverage and organ dose objectives across the treatment fields.
Discrete optimization of plate positions
For a plan with three fields, the processor enumerates the feasible combinations of inserted and retracted plate positions and solves for spot weights for each combination. It selects the feasible combination with the lowest dose objective value and records the plate position for each field.
Section 3 · quoted from USPTO records
Other work
Passages reproduced word for word from two earlier-published U.S. patent documents, placed beside the language of claim 1. No characterization is offered. Each passage is marked A or B for the document it comes from; ¶ numbers are the paragraph numbers in the USPTO’s published full text of that document.
1.1by a control circuit: accessing an availability selection regarding usage of the selectively deployable range shifter
The first and second range shifter settings may, respectively, be set automatically by the system, or may be set based on user input indicating a range shifter setting selection.
B · US 11,565,127 B2 · ¶ 51
1.2optimizing the proton therapy treatment plan to provide an optimized proton therapy treatment plan
A robustness-optimized proton therapy plan 50 is thus generated, including robustness optimized parameters 52.
A · US 2019/0290931 A1 · ¶ 25
In one or more embodiments, the data processor 110 is configured to, as a part of optimizing the at least one set of sub-beams to determine a treatment plan, optimize at least one set of sub-beams based on an optimization objective unique to that set of sub-beams.
B · US 11,565,127 B2 · ¶ 30
1.3wherein the optimizing includes optimizing selective use of the selectively deployable range shifter.
In this case, the selection of no range shifter (range shifter with thickness T2=0) is the selection that best achieves minimization of unwanted dose, while maintaining or improving target dose coverage.
B · US 11,565,127 B2 · ¶ 59
An empty cell means only that no passage was reproduced there.
Statements in these documents
For example, the distal dose fall-off for protons is very sharp, on the order of millimeters, enabling precise tumor targeting with small margins.
A · US 2019/0290931 A1 · ¶ 3
Range uncertainty can similarly lead to detrimental dose misplacement.
A · US 2019/0290931 A1 · ¶ 3
More particularly, the invention relates to a system, and a corresponding method, for determining a treatment plan for active ion beam treatment, such that both unwanted dose minimization and maintained or maximized target dose coverage is obtained.
B · US 11,565,127 B2 · ¶ 2
The inventor has therefore found that, in ion beam radiation treatment of a target volume, there is a need for minimizing dose to organs-at-risk (OAR), while maintaining or improving target coverage.
B · US 11,565,127 B2 · ¶ 7
Cite aspatent.fyi, US 2026/0355538 A1, claim 1, first published 2026-11-19T12:45:34-05:00, https://patent.fyi/US20260355538/, SHA-256 e8ec69e0590a377e2bd74b3a8a790f6685fdf8d4ff6bf93db9a9eb7680bb541a