Questions about how individual parts of claim 1 might be changed. A question may describe something different from what the claim language recites, or a version of it; no view is offered on which.
1.1Methacrolein from isobutylene oxidation
What ifWhat if vapor-phase isobutylene oxidation supplies the methacrolein intermediate?
Claim language“reacting propionaldehyde and formaldehyde”
A cooled tubular reactor passes isobutylene, air, and steam over a bismuth molybdate catalyst. The catalyst oxidizes an allylic methyl group to an aldehyde, and a downstream quench cools the methacrolein-containing effluent.
1.3Separate oxidation and esterification
What ifWhat if a gas-phase oxidation reactor produces methacrylic acid for a separate acid-catalyzed esterification reactor?
A molybdenum–vanadium mixed oxide catalyst oxidizes methacrolein with air to form methacrylic acid. A separate reactor contacts the recovered acid with methanol over a sulfonated resin, and downstream separation removes the water formed during esterification.
1.3Short residence without inhibitor
What ifWhat if the oxidative esterification reactor operates without a polymerization inhibitor?
Claim language“at least one inhibitor”
A cooled, low-holdup packed bed brings methacrolein, methanol, and an oxygen-containing gas into contact with the solid catalyst. High liquid throughput limits the residence time of the ester in the warm reactor, and an outlet heat exchanger cools the effluent immediately.
1.4Isobutyrate removal by rectification
What ifWhat if the recovered methyl methacrylate stream contains less than 0.1 ppm methyl isobutyrate?
Claim language“from 0.1 to 5000 ppm of an alkyl isobutyrate”
A rectification column concentrates the more volatile methyl isobutyrate in a light-ends purge. The column uses a high stage count and reflux to sharpen the split, and a calibrated trace gas chromatographic method checks the methyl methacrylate stream against the 0.1 ppm target.
1.4Heavy adduct removal by evaporation
What ifWhat if the recovered methyl methacrylate stream contains less than 0.01 weight percent methyl 3-methoxy-2-methylpropanoate?
Claim language“from 0.01 to 5 weight % of at least one Michael addition product”
A wiped-film evaporator under vacuum transfers methyl methacrylate into the vapor phase and retains most of the higher-boiling methanol addition product in the liquid residue. A second vacuum separation polishes the condensate, and gas chromatography measures the residual adduct.
Section 2 · machine-generated
Variations
Further arrangements of the same subject matter, described here as of the publication date at the foot of this page.
Other field of use
Monomer feed for acrylic fiber spinning
A monomer unit at an acrylic fiber plant reacts propionaldehyde with formaldehyde and conditions the resulting methacrolein by phase separation and distillation. An oxidative esterification reactor combines the conditioned methacrolein with methanol, a polymerization inhibitor, an oxygen-containing gas, and a gold-on-metal-oxide catalyst. A finishing column and an inhibited surge tank supply methyl methacrylate to a metering pump, which feeds it as a comonomer to the acrylonitrile polymerization reactor upstream of solution spinning.
Component substitution
Centrifugal separation of condensed methacrolein
A continuous disc-stack centrifuge replaces the gravity decanter on the cooled methacrolein intermediate stream. The centrifuge sends the denser aqueous phase to a separate outlet and the methacrolein-rich phase to a distillation column. The column removes dimer in a heavy stream and sends the conditioned methacrolein to oxidative esterification after the outlet water and dimer concentrations each fall below 10 weight percent.
Cerium oxide support for gold
Cerium dioxide particles replace alumina particles as the support for gold in the oxidative esterification catalyst. Deposition–precipitation places gold on the cerium dioxide, and washing, drying, and calcination prepare the supported particles for a stirred slurry reactor. The reactor contacts the catalyst with conditioned methacrolein, alkyl alcohol, a polymerization inhibitor, and an oxygen-containing gas, and an outlet filter retains the particles as the liquid product leaves.
Parameter or scale variation
Two parallel oxidative esterification trains
A common phase separation and distillation section supplies conditioned methacrolein to two parallel stirred reactors, each sized for 50 percent of the total design throughput. Independent flow controllers split the methacrolein equally and meter alcohol, inhibitor, and oxygen-containing gas into each reactor. Each reactor retains its gold-on-metal-oxide catalyst with a liquid outlet filter, and the two filtrate streams join upstream of product recovery.
Combination with existing systems
Alcohol recovery with membrane drying
After catalyst separation, a recovery column separates excess methanol from the methyl methacrylate product stream. The condensed methanol-rich overhead passes through a water-selective pervaporation module that draws the water-rich permeate into a vacuum-side condenser. The methanol-rich retentate returns to the esterification feed tank, where a flow controller adds fresh methanol to maintain the alcohol-to-methacrolein feed ratio.
Specific version of a part
Water removal by adsorption
A distillation column takes a methacrolein-rich vapor overhead and leaves the higher-boiling dimer in the bottoms. A heated transfer line keeps the overhead in the vapor phase as it passes through a 3-angstrom molecular sieve bed, which adsorbs water before the vapor reaches the condenser.
Aqueous amine condensation
A stirred reactor mixes propionaldehyde with aqueous formaldehyde and a dimethylamine–acetic acid catalyst system. The condensation forms a carbon–carbon bond, and dehydration yields methacrolein.
Decanter and vacuum column
A cooled gravity decanter withdraws the water-rich phase from the crude intermediate. A vacuum column takes methacrolein overhead and removes higher-boiling dimer in the bottoms, with outlet targets below 5 weight percent each for water and dimer.
Gold on titanium dioxide
A liquid-phase packed bed holds titanium dioxide pellets bearing dispersed gold particles. Methacrolein and methanol flow through the bed with diluted air, and a controlled feed of 4-methoxyphenol suppresses polymerization.
Specified methyl ester impurities
The methyl methacrylate product stream contains 50 ppm by mass methyl isobutyrate and 0.20 weight percent methyl 3-methoxy-2-methylpropanoate. A calibrated gas chromatographic method reports both concentrations on the total stream mass basis.
Section 3 · quoted from USPTO records
Other work
Passages reproduced word for word from two earlier-published U.S. patent documents, placed beside the language of claim 1. No characterization is offered. Each passage is marked A or B for the document it comes from; ¶ numbers are the paragraph numbers in the USPTO’s published full text of that document.
1.1(a) reacting propionaldehyde and formaldehyde to produce a methacrolein intermediate stream;
The process according to the invention comprises, in process step A), the preparation of methacrolein by reaction of propanal with formaldehyde via an aldol or Mannich condensation.
A · US 9,580,374 B2 · ¶ 59
In a development of the process the methacrolein is obtained from propanal and formaldehyde in the first stage.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 3
1.2(b) subjecting the methacrolein intermediate stream produced in step (a) to at least one phase separation and at least one distillation to reduce an amount of methacrolein dimer and water in the methacrolein intermediate stream, wherein the amount of methacrolein dimer exiting the at least one phase separation and at least one distillation is less than 10 weight % based on the total weight of the methacrolein intermediate stream exiting the at least one phase separation and the at least one distillation, and the amount of water exiting the at least one phase separation and the at least one distillation is less than 10 weight % based on the total weight of the methacrolein intermediate stream exiting the at least one phase separation and the at least one distillation;
B) isolating liquid crude methacrolein by distillation in a first distillation column and subsequently separating from an aqueous phase; C) distilling the crude methacrolein obtained from step B) in a second distillation column in the presence of methanol;
A · US 9,580,374 B2 · claim 1
The product mixture at the outflow of the tubular reactor is depressurized via a valve and enters the product column for the distillation. At the top of this column, after condensation and phase separation, a biphasic mixture of methacrolein and an aqueous phase is obtained.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 48
1.3(c) reacting the methacrolein with an alkyl alcohol in an oxidative esterification reaction system in the presence of at least one inhibitor, an oxygen-containing gas, and a catalyst comprising gold particles and particles of at least one metal oxide to produce a product stream comprising an alkyl methacrylate, wherein the metal of the at least one metal oxide is selected from aluminum, titanium, lanthanides, zirconium, alkali metals, alkaline earth metals, nickel, cobalt, zinc, magnesium, tellurium, antimony, rhenium, tungsten, and bismuth;
D) subsequently oxidatively esterifying the methacrolein obtained from step C) with methanol and oxygen in the presence of a heterogeneous noble metal-containing oxidation catalyst comprising metals and/or metal oxides in a reactor; and E) distilling the product obtained from step D) in a distillation column, and recycling a distillate comprising methacrolein and methanol into the reactor of step D).
A · US 9,580,374 B2 · claim 1
Oxidative esterification of the methacrolein to afford an alkyl methacrylate and recycling of the methacrolein (1) formalin feed into reactor I (2) propanal feed into reactor I (3) optional stabilizer feed into reactor I (4) reactor I for methacrolein synthesis (5) workup of the crude methacrolein (6) methacrolein feed into reactor II (7) reactor II for oxidative esterification of the methacrolein (8) alcohol feed (generally methanol feed) (9) oxygen/air feed (10) base feed (
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 118
1.4wherein the product stream comprises from 0.1 to 5000 ppm of an alkyl isobutyrate and from 0.01 to 5 weight % of at least one Michael addition product based on the total weight of the product stream.
MMA: 19.2% by weight MeOH: 27.5% by weight Methacrolein: 5.6% by weight Methyl methoxyisobutyrate (MMIB): 0.5% by weight Methacrylic acid: 0.5% by weight Water: 44.0% by weight MAL acetal: 1 ppm
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶
An empty cell means only that no passage was reproduced there.
Statements in these documents
It is a feature of this novel process that it was possible to distinctly increase the yield and the efficiency of the process compared to the prior art through a sequence of different distillation steps.
A · US 9,580,374 B2 · ¶ 1
Further problems with all the processes described above are especially also the relatively unsatisfactory yields, high losses in the oxidation steps and hence, in general, associated by-product formation—for example of CO2,—which entail complex process steps for isolation of the product.
A · US 9,580,374 B2 · ¶ 7
In particular, the present invention relates to an optimized workup of the reactor output from the oxidative esterification of methacrolein by means of which unconverted methacrolein (MAL) can be recycled very efficiently.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 2
In addition, this novel process can be carried out in a manner which compared to known variants is markedly more energy- and water-saving.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 2
Cite aspatent.fyi, US 2026/0356789 A1, claim 1, first published 2026-11-20T06:49:46-05:00, https://patent.fyi/US20260356789/, SHA-256 68173ce42d4ee3ee2e9813c70776fb7a75ec213a3db7f5cbb5b0485d5b54c6a9