Questions about how individual parts of claim 1 might be changed. A question may describe something different from what the claim language recites, or a version of it; no view is offered on which.
1.1Direct methacrylic acid esterification
What ifWhat if methacrylic acid and an alkyl alcohol serve as the esterification feed?
Claim language“reacting methacrolein with an alkyl alcohol”
A sulfonated resin catalyzes the reaction of methacrylic acid with methanol to form methyl methacrylate and water. A distillation loop removes water from the reaction mixture and returns recovered methanol to the reactor.
1.1Liquid oxidant for ester formation
What ifWhat if an aqueous chlorite solution supplies the oxidizing capacity for ester production?
Claim language“an oxygen-containing gas”
Buffered aqueous sodium chlorite oxidizes methacrolein to methacrylic acid, and an alkene scavenger consumes hypochlorous acid formed during oxidation. After residual oxidant is quenched, the methacrylic acid is recovered by solvent extraction and esterified with methanol over an acidic resin.
1.2Membrane recovery of methanol
What ifWhat if a pervaporation membrane recovers methanol from the esterification effluent?
A methanol-selective membrane takes up methanol from the liquid feed, and vacuum on the permeate side draws it off as vapor for condensation. A short-residence vacuum flash removes residual methacrolein from the ester-rich retentate for separate recovery.
1.2Separate aldehyde and alcohol recovery
What ifWhat if the process recovers methacrolein ahead of the alcohol recovery column and draws the alcohol from that column as a side stream?
Claim language“an overhead stream comprising alkyl alcohol and methacrolein”
An upstream stripping column removes the bulk of the methacrolein in a condensable vapor stream. In the alcohol recovery column, a small overhead purge removes residual light compounds, a liquid side draw recovers methanol, and the bottoms carry the ester and heavier compounds.
1.3Vacuum removal of heavy acetals
What ifWhat if vacuum fractionation separates methyl methacrylate from the acetal-containing fraction?
Claim language“an acetal hydrolysis reactor”
A water wash removes residual methanol, and a settler feeds the organic phase to a vacuum column. The column takes methyl methacrylate overhead and withdraws the higher-boiling methacrolein dimethyl acetal with the bottoms.
Section 2 · machine-generated
Variations
Further arrangements of the same subject matter, described here as of the publication date at the foot of this page.
Other field of use
Monomer production for optical casting
An optical sheet casting plant produces methyl methacrylate from methacrolein and methanol in a reactor supplied with an inhibitor, an oxygen-containing gas, and a supported noble metal catalyst. An alcohol recovery column sends methanol and methacrolein overhead and sends its bottoms through an acetal hydrolysis reactor and a liquid-liquid separator. A vacuum finishing column takes methyl methacrylate as a distillate from the separated organic phase, and a filtration skid delivers it to an inhibited monomer tank that supplies the casting line.
Component substitution
Disc stack centrifuge for phase separation
A continuous disc stack centrifuge serves as the phase separator downstream of the acetal hydrolysis reactor. A heat exchanger cools the hydrolysis effluent before a low-shear feed pump delivers it to the centrifuge. The disc stack shortens the settling distance between the liquid phases, and separate outlets discharge the lighter methacrylate-rich phase and the denser aqueous phase.
Fixed bed with solid acid resin
A packed bed of macroporous sulfonated polystyrene resin supplies the acid sites for acetal hydrolysis. A static mixer combines the alcohol recovery bottoms with a metered water stream before a distributor feeds the mixture down through the resin bed. Retaining screens hold the resin in the vessel, and the bed effluent flows to a liquid-liquid separator.
Parameter or scale variation
Two stages for continuous acetal hydrolysis
Two jacketed stirred tanks operate in series at a combined liquid feed rate of 100 liters per hour. The first tank receives the alcohol recovery bottoms, water, and aqueous acid, and each tank maintains a working volume of 50 liters for a nominal residence time of 30 minutes per stage. Impellers disperse the aqueous phase in each tank, and the second tank discharges through a cooler to the phase separator.
Combination with existing systems
Steam stripping of separator water
A packed steam stripping column receives the aqueous outlet of the phase separator through a surge tank. Steam enters beneath the packing and carries dissolved methacrolein and alcohol into the overhead vapor. An overhead condenser returns part of the condensate as reflux and sends the balance to the alcohol recovery column. A level controller regulates the stripped water discharge from the base of the stripper.
Automated or data-driven variant
Chromatographic control of hydrolysis water
An online gas chromatograph samples the alcohol recovery bottoms and the organic phase leaving the separator through two conditioned sample loops. A controller multiplies the inlet acetal concentration by the measured bottoms flow to calculate the incoming acetal load and set the hydrolysis water flow. The controller trims that setpoint using the measured residual acetal concentration in the organic outlet and adjusts a metering pump to deliver the commanded water flow.
Specific version of a part
Supported gold slurry reactor
A stirred tank suspends gold-on-silica catalyst particles in a methacrolein and methanol feed containing a phenolic polymerization inhibitor. A sparger disperses oxygen diluted with nitrogen, and a liquid outlet filter retains the catalyst particles.
Packed vacuum recovery column
Structured packing contacts rising vapor with descending reflux under reduced pressure. An overhead condenser collects methanol and methacrolein, and the liquid bottoms carry methyl methacrylate, methyl isobutyrate, and methacrolein acetals.
Stirred aqueous acetal hydrolysis
A stirred tank disperses dilute aqueous sulfuric acid through the ester-rich column bottoms. Water cleaves methacrolein acetals into methacrolein and alcohol, and the reactor discharge flows to a gravity settler.
Horizontal settler with coalescing plates
Inclined plates coalesce dispersed droplets as the hydrolysis effluent flows through a horizontal vessel. An interface controller regulates the lower aqueous outlet, and an overflow weir collects the upper ester-rich phase.
Section 3 · quoted from USPTO records
Other work
Passages reproduced word for word from two earlier-published U.S. patent documents, placed beside the language of claim 1. No characterization is offered. Each passage is marked A or B for the document it comes from; ¶ numbers are the paragraph numbers in the USPTO’s published full text of that document.
1.1reacting methacrolein with an alkyl alcohol in an oxidative esterification reaction (OER) system in the presence of at least one inhibitor, an oxygen-containing gas, and a noble metal-containing catalyst comprising to produce an OER product stream comprising an alkyl methacrylate, an alkyl isobutyrate in an amount ranging from 0.1 to 5000 ppm, and at least one Michael addition product in an amount ranging from 0.01 to 5 weight % based on the total weight of the OER product stream;
In the oxidative esterification reactor, an oxygen-containing gas was supplied to the mixed solution of the methacrolein and the methanol in the presence of a catalyst, to subject the mixed solution to an oxidative esterification reaction.
A · US 11,414,371 B2 · ¶ 98
In this second stage a liquid mixture of methacrolein and methanol with reduced water content is reacted with molecular oxygen and a palladium catalyst, wherein said catalyst is usually in supported form as a palladium-lead catalyst.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 13
1.2feeding the OER product stream to an alcohol recovery distillation column to provide an overhead stream comprising alkyl alcohol and methacrolein and a bottoms stream comprising alkyl methacrylate, alkyl isobutyrate, acetals and/or hemiacetals of methacrolein; and
[1] A method for producing methyl methacrylate, comprising: a distillation step comprising supplying a reaction solution, which is obtained by subjecting methacrolein, methanol, and molecular oxygen to oxidative esterification in an oxidative esterification reactor and which comprises the methyl methacrylate as a reaction product, to a first distillation column located at downstream of the oxidative esterification reactor, extracting a fraction comprising the methacrolein and
A · US 11,414,371 B2 · ¶ 9
In this first distillation, more or less the entirety of the methacrolein, and portions of methanol, MMA and water, are taken off at the column top (14) and returned into the DOE reactor (7). The bottoms of the column contain MMA, water and methanol and also methacrylic acid and methacrylic acid salt, and high-boiling by-products.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 101
1.3feeding the bottoms stream of the alcohol recovery distillation column to an acetal hydrolysis reactor and a phase separator.
Before the step of phase-separating the column bottom liquid into the light phase and the heavy phase, it is more preferable to add a strong acid, and optionally water, followed by mixing, decompose methacrolein dimethyl acetal and the like which may be contained in the reaction solution, and neutralize sodium methacrylate for phase-shifting as methacrylic acid to the light phase.
A · US 11,414,371 B2 · ¶ 82
An empty cell means only that no passage was reproduced there.
Statements in these documents
Thus, from the viewpoint of reducing energy required for distillation, and suppressing the blockage of the distillation column to achieve a long-term stable operation, there is still room for improvement in the technique of Patent Literature 1.
A · US 11,414,371 B2 · ¶ 5
The present invention has been made in view of the problems of the conventional technique, and an object of the present invention is to provide a method for producing methyl methacrylate which can achieve a more efficient and stable operation when the methyl methacrylate is produced.
A · US 11,414,371 B2 · ¶ 6
In particular, the present invention relates to an optimized workup of the reactor output from the oxidative esterification of methacrolein by means of which unconverted methacrolein (MAL) can be recycled very efficiently.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 2
In addition, this novel process can be carried out in a manner which compared to known variants is markedly more energy- and water-saving.
B · US 2022/0363625 A1 · ¶ 2
Cite aspatent.fyi, US 2026/0356790 A1, claim 1, first published 2026-11-20T06:49:46-05:00, https://patent.fyi/US20260356790/, SHA-256 811f5b9c727a38148c78479b917b98f1d99326cbd8a3c900e5484449ac7a78b9